Mankind Should Have Won the "I Quit" match against The Rock

[Swiss Ultimate]

Originally Posted by The Midnight Gertner Austin won the Rumble making it Mankind vs Austin for the title. If you want to keep Rock vs Austin for the title, Mankind would have had to lose it next month anyways.

Let me look at the title timeline.

Okay...

So we had The Rock

NOV 15, 1998 - JAN 4, 1999

50 days

Mankind then won his first title from The Rock on Jan 4th.

Mankind

JAN 4, 1999 - JAN 24, 1999

20 days

Rock won it back for 7 days followed by Mankind for 15 days.

My proposal would have been for a single 42 day reign plus his last reign. Let the guy win 6 or so title defenses before having Rock get the title back. I'm perfectly fine with his "second reign" lasting one day.

However, if I would go any further I'd never feud Triple H and Vince and I'd never have Vince win the title and Big Show would not have been champ ever.

There's so much that was great and done perfectly, but I contend that Mankind having two short reigns sucked, especially for die-hard Foley fans.