Is Impact Wrestling the best American promotion currently?

[xrodmuc316]

Originally Posted by Simple Fan Just because previous regime's made bad decisions doesn't mean Impact is bad. They've really stepped up their game this year. Don Callis and Scott D'Amore have been great for the company. As a guy that watches ROH and a weekly basis I promise you it doesn't top Impact. They don't even try to make their TV match up with live events or shows with NJPW. Being the Elite carries more storylines than ROH TV does. I won't disagree on Lucha Underground because its great but its not your typical promotion. Impact gets to use Lucha Underground talent and use them well. They also work with House of Hardcore which I also watch, good show but it doesn't have as much as Impact does. The NWA has put out some great stuff on YouTube and will be putting on their first show later this month. Impact has a solid 2 hour wrestling show every week that has something for preety much everybody. It's not geared towards kids but it is kid safe. I feel like they've taken an old school approach to their booking with none of the shady things that TNA had a reputation of doing. Just my personal opinion but you should watch more wrestling.

I may have got a little carried away, but I stand by the sentiment.

I watch plenty of wrestling, and I enjoy multiple promotions more. Impact is simply not as polished, interesting, or consistent enough for me to rate it better than ROH, Lucha Underground, House of Hardcore, PWG, CZW, and a handful of others.

This has always been the argument for TNA, for 15 years people say it is the best just because it's not WWE, and it just never has been, and it certainly isn't as good as it has been in the past either.