Help me re-organize the "Staff Picks" section at my video store

OK, I am basically trying to re-organize it. I have room on the shelves for 70 movies. These are the ones that are definitely in. This list has 53 movies (21 of which we also have on DVD), so that leaves room for 17 more. NOTE: This does not include comedies. They have their own staff picks section.

12 Angry Men
Adaptation (DVD)
American Beauty (DVD)
American History X
Barton Fink
Being John Malkovich
Boiler Room
Boogie Nights
Bound
Blood Simple
Blue Velvet
Bully (DVD)
Clockwork Orange
Casino
Carlito's Way
Donnie Brasco (DVD)
Dog Day Afternoon
Do the Right Thing
Eyes Wide Shut (DVD)
Full Metal Jacket (DVD)
Fargo
Goodfellas (DVD)
Glengarry Glen Ross
Happiness
Insomnia (DVD)
Jackie Brown
Kids
Lolita
Mulholland Dr. (DVD)
Memento (DVD)
Magnolia
Menace II Society
Miller's Crossing
Of Mice and Men
Once Upon a Time in America
One Hour Photo (DVD)
The Others (DVD)
Pulp Fiction (DVD)
Punch-Drunk Love (DVD)
Rain Man
Reservoir Dogs (DVD)
Raging Bull (DVD)
Run Lola Run
Sling Blade
Shining (DVD)
Scarface (DVD)
Sea of Love
Storytelling
True Romance
Taxi Driver (DVD)
Vanilla Sky (DVD)
Welcome to the Dollhouse
Y Tu Mama Tambien (DVD)

NOW...

This is the list of movies that have previously been in the section. Keep in mind they are not all necessarily my picks, but yeah, this is what I have to choose from that has been there before... Basically, which movies would you definitely add out of the list below? Or which movies would you add that are NOT on the list above? Keep in mind that it all depends on if we have them at the store or not, so if it's some really rare shit, we probably won't. Anyway, suggest some stuff.

2001 Space Oddyssey
400 Blows
American Psycho
And Justice For All
As Good as it Gets
Bad Lieutenant
Born on the 4th of July
Bronx Tale
Basic Instinct
Devil's Advocate
Drugstore Cowboy
Elephant Man
Face/Off
Falling Down
Fatal Attraction
Fight Club
Forrest Gump
Few Good Men
Gladiator
Hard Eight
Hate
Honeymoon Killers
In the Company of Men
Jungle Fever
King of New York
LA Confidential
Lost Highway
Ocean's 11
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
People vs. Larry Flint
Primal Fear
The Professional
Psycho
Rear Window
Rounders
Requiem for a Dream
Stand by Me
Shawshank Redemption
Saving Private Ryan
Seven
Silence of the Lambs
Sleepers
Saturday Night Fever
Serpico
Scent of a Woman
Time to Kill
Usual Suspects
You Can Count on Me

I am also trying to order these off eBay:

Amores Perros
Paths of Glory
Freaks
Eraserhead
Audition
Ichi the Killer
Show Me Love