Official Rate The Wrestler Discussion Thread

**BigDaddyCool** · 11-02-2004, 04:23 AM

That's right, I made a thread discussing another thread (this one I think accutally merits a thread to discuss it though). For the past 71 days, we as a forum have embarked on a quest to discuss and rank all the wrestlers in the world. And during this, many questions have been raise, and few have been answered. So all questions, and disagreements with voting or what ever should be done here.

Also, I have listed all the wrestlers ranked so far, in decending order:
Bret Hart 96
Kurt Angle 96
Owen Hart 95
Ted DeBiase 95
Steve Austin 93
Brian Pillman 92
Shawn Micheals 92
Arn Anderson 92
The Rock 92
Chris Jericho 91
Sting 91
Curt Henning 91
Eddie Guerrero 91
Randy Savage 91
Ricky Steamboat 90
A.J. Styles 89
William Regal 89
Jushin Lyger 88
Mick Foley 88
Chris Beniot 88
Harley Race 88
Undertaker 88
Jake the Snake 88
Raven 87
Ric Flair 87
Hayabusa 87
Lance Storm 85
Ultimo Dragon 84
Davey Boy Smith 84
Kane 84
Booker T 84
American Dragon 84
Christian 83
Scott Hall 83
Jerry Lynn 83
Kanyon 83
Taz 82
Hulk Hogan 82
Randy Orton 82
Matt Hardy 82
CM Punk 82
Rey Mystero Jr. 81
HHH 81
Al Snow 81
DDP 80
Andre the Gaint 80
Petey Williams 79
RVD 78
Brock Lesnar 78
Vader 78
Doink 78
John Cena 77
The Hurricane 76
Sean O'Haire 76
Val Venis 75
Low Ki 73
Steve Corino 73
Alex Wright 73
Jamie Noble 73
Jeff Hardy 69
Jim Niedhart 66
Jeff Jarrett 65
Goldberg 64
Kevin Nash 61
Big Vito 60
X-Pac 60
Buff Bagwell 56
Lex Luger 55
Psycho Sid 51
Bradshaw 46
Bob Holly 34

**Mr. Nerfect** · 11-02-2004, 04:38 AM

I really think Hardcore should have gotten more than a 34. That lowers him down to an average of a "D" class wrestler, and I dont believe that to be true. Bob Holly is easily a C or a B grade wrestler, which puts him somewhere in the 40-80 range. JBl also scored a bit too low, IMO.

**John la Rock** · 11-02-2004, 04:46 AM

Hardcore's 34 is well deserving

But JBL did get way too low. I gave him a 5 mostly because I was pissed off of his actions in Germany and the fact that he just won the WWE title. But since JBL won the title he has been so entertaining and the best heel on Smackdown. If I could I would change my vote to a 7.5

Also AJ Styles got WAY too high

**Mr. Nerfect** · 11-02-2004, 06:37 AM

I agree with AJ Styles. I'd give him somewhere between a 7 and an 8, but it looks for every 8 there was a 10.

**BabyHugger** · 11-02-2004, 07:49 AM

Is this by wrestling ability, or the total package? Cause I think Kane is a way better wrestler than the Undertaker. Also the Rock is a terrible wrestler IMO.

**Mister Sinister** · 11-02-2004, 07:51 AM

Grian Pillman? Who Be That ^_^

**Loose Cannon** · 11-02-2004, 10:24 AM

Yea, CM Punk tying with Hogan is crazy. This should of been based on the whole package, but if people were basing it just on wrestling skills, then I see why he tied Hogan

Hogan should have been in the high 80's for all he did for the business.

**Mister Sinister** · 11-02-2004, 12:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Loose Cannon

Yea, CM Punk tying with Hogan is crazy. This should of been based on the whole package, but if people were basing it just on wrestling skills, then I see why he tied Hogan

Hogan should have been in the high 80's for all he did for the business.

But you're forgetting, not everyone, actually does what I want them to do, which is Rate is on everything (Looks, What They Done, Skills, The Whole Thing) and give people 1's based on one thing, which varies...People look at Hogan as a Bad Wrestler and give him a 1 without adding in, what he has done...I've only been negitive repped three times since I been here, and one person actually gave me Negitive Rep...just because Hogan scored a 82, like it was my fault (BTW, I scored Hogan a 8.6)

I admit, while AJ may be the most talented wrestler on the List (Among Active Wrestlers) he is rated a bit too High, A 8.5 or lower should be good for him, however some people rate people way to high much of the time, or rate them really low.....But Oh Well, I can't do nothing about it

**BigDaddyCool** · 11-02-2004, 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Helmsphere

I admit, while AJ may be the worst wrestler on the List (Among Active Wrestlers), he is rated a way too High, A 5.5 or lower should be good for him, however some people rate people way to high much of the time, or rate them really low.....But Oh Well, I can't do nothing about it

There, I fixed it.

**John la Rock** · 11-02-2004, 04:16 PM

Also HHH getting an 81 is a shame. Man people need to stop carring only about politics

**Mr. Nerfect** · 11-02-2004, 06:29 PM

I agree with Hogan and Triple H deserving a higher score. Triple H deserves a nine for his mic skills, technical ability, brawling, and his psychology. Hogan deserves a nine for basically renovating wrestling single-handedly, and becomming one of the most classic faces and heels respectively of all time, IMO.

11-02-2004, 04:23 AM	#1
BigDaddyCool Pelvic Sorcerer Posts: 64,762	Official Rate The Wrestler Discussion Thread That's right, I made a thread discussing another thread (this one I think accutally merits a thread to discuss it though). For the past 71 days, we as a forum have embarked on a quest to discuss and rank all the wrestlers in the world. And during this, many questions have been raise, and few have been answered. So all questions, and disagreements with voting or what ever should be done here. Also, I have listed all the wrestlers ranked so far, in decending order: Bret Hart 96 Kurt Angle 96 Owen Hart 95 Ted DeBiase 95 Steve Austin 93 Brian Pillman 92 Shawn Micheals 92 Arn Anderson 92 The Rock 92 Chris Jericho 91 Sting 91 Curt Henning 91 Eddie Guerrero 91 Randy Savage 91 Ricky Steamboat 90 A.J. Styles 89 William Regal 89 Jushin Lyger 88 Mick Foley 88 Chris Beniot 88 Harley Race 88 Undertaker 88 Jake the Snake 88 Raven 87 Ric Flair 87 Hayabusa 87 Lance Storm 85 Ultimo Dragon 84 Davey Boy Smith 84 Kane 84 Booker T 84 American Dragon 84 Christian 83 Scott Hall 83 Jerry Lynn 83 Kanyon 83 Taz 82 Hulk Hogan 82 Randy Orton 82 Matt Hardy 82 CM Punk 82 Rey Mystero Jr. 81 HHH 81 Al Snow 81 DDP 80 Andre the Gaint 80 Petey Williams 79 RVD 78 Brock Lesnar 78 Vader 78 Doink 78 John Cena 77 The Hurricane 76 Sean O'Haire 76 Val Venis 75 Low Ki 73 Steve Corino 73 Alex Wright 73 Jamie Noble 73 Jeff Hardy 69 Jim Niedhart 66 Jeff Jarrett 65 Goldberg 64 Kevin Nash 61 Big Vito 60 X-Pac 60 Buff Bagwell 56 Lex Luger 55 Psycho Sid 51 Bradshaw 46 Bob Holly 34 Last edited by BigDaddyCool; 11-02-2004 at 01:56 PM.

11-02-2004, 04:38 AM	#2
Mr. Nerfect Posts: 61,634	I really think Hardcore should have gotten more than a 34. That lowers him down to an average of a "D" class wrestler, and I dont believe that to be true. Bob Holly is easily a C or a B grade wrestler, which puts him somewhere in the 40-80 range. JBl also scored a bit too low, IMO.

11-02-2004, 04:46 AM	#3
John la Rock That's how I roll!!! Posts: 4,437	Hardcore's 34 is well deserving But JBL did get way too low. I gave him a 5 mostly because I was pissed off of his actions in Germany and the fact that he just won the WWE title. But since JBL won the title he has been so entertaining and the best heel on Smackdown. If I could I would change my vote to a 7.5 Also AJ Styles got WAY too high

11-02-2004, 06:37 AM	#4
Mr. Nerfect Posts: 61,634	I agree with AJ Styles. I'd give him somewhere between a 7 and an 8, but it looks for every 8 there was a 10.

11-02-2004, 07:49 AM	#5
BabyHugger MJwO Posts: 3,157	Is this by wrestling ability, or the total package? Cause I think Kane is a way better wrestler than the Undertaker. Also the Rock is a terrible wrestler IMO.

11-02-2004, 07:51 AM	#6
Mister Sinister Less Talk, More Rokk! Posts: 3,555	Grian Pillman? Who Be That ^_^

11-02-2004, 10:24 AM	#7
Loose Cannon I'm all there is Posts: 31,811	Yea, CM Punk tying with Hogan is crazy. This should of been based on the whole package, but if people were basing it just on wrestling skills, then I see why he tied Hogan Hogan should have been in the high 80's for all he did for the business.

11-02-2004, 04:16 PM	#10
John la Rock That's how I roll!!! Posts: 4,437	Also HHH getting an 81 is a shame. Man people need to stop carring only about politics

11-02-2004, 06:29 PM	#11
Mr. Nerfect Posts: 61,634	I agree with Hogan and Triple H deserving a higher score. Triple H deserves a nine for his mic skills, technical ability, brawling, and his psychology. Hogan deserves a nine for basically renovating wrestling single-handedly, and becomming one of the most classic faces and heels respectively of all time, IMO.